A Place of Execution

Discussing Books
Home	Reviews	Critiques	Picks of the Month	Games	Links	Contact me

Val McDermid, A Place of Execution

In 1963, thirteen-year-old Alison Carter disappears from Scardale, a hamlet in Derbyshire, England. For recently promoted inspector George Bennett, it is an opportunity to demonstrate his skills, but it will soon also become a personal crusade: learning that his wife Anne is pregnant, Bennett feels he has a responsibility towards other parents, and in this case, to Alison's mother Ruth...

However, despite Bennett's eagerness, Alison is not found, and, as days passes, very few clues tell the story of what happened to her on the cold December night of her disappearance. Her dog was found unharmed, but, later on, some gruesome discoveries let Bennett think the worse...

Thirty-five years later, journalist Catherine Heathcote decides to write a book about Alison Carter's disappearance. George Bennett cooperates, until one day he withdraws his consent for the publication of the book without a word of explanation. What terrible knowledge did he uncover about a case long closed? What could prompt this honest detective to want the truth hidden?

A Place of Execution is a very suspenseful mystery, with an ending I hadn't been expecting. Event though I found it was a bit light on the characterization (as regular visitors of this web site know, I usually favor mysteries with a psychological depth such as Elizabeth George's or Ruth Rendell's novels), this one had the originality to go beyond the boundaries of a traditional police investigation. It is not its only merit, since the solution to the mystery seemed fresh and original even to a mystery lover like me. I am glad to have discovered another good mystery writer and I'll be looking for other mysteries by Val McDermid...

Rating:

By Val McDermid:

McDermid, Val (1987) Report For Murder

McDermid, Val (1989) Common Murder

McDermid, Val (1991) Final Edition

McDermid, Val (1992) Dead Beat

McDermid, Val (1993) Union Jack

McDermid, Val (1993) Kick Back

McDermid, Val (1994) Crackdown

McDermid, Val (1994) A Suitable Job for a Woman (Non Fiction)

McDermid, Val (1995) Clean Break

McDermid, Val (1995) The Mermaids Singing

McDermid, Val (1996) Blue Genes

McDermid, Val (1996) Booked For Murder

McDermid, Val (1997) The Wire in the Blood

McDermid, Val (1997) The Writing on the Wall and Other Stories (Short Stories)

McDermid, Val (1998) Star Struck

McDermid, Val (1999) A Place of Execution

McDermid, Val (2000) Killing the Shadows

McDermid, Val (2002) The Last Temptation

McDermid, Val (2003) The Distant Echo

Links:

Val McDermid Official Web Site